NA62-Supervision, Appraisal and Reflective Practice Policy
{{org_field_logo}}
{{org_field_name}}
Registration Number: {{org_field_registration_no}}
Supervision, Appraisal and Reflective Practice Policy
1. Purpose
The purpose of this policy is to provide a comprehensive framework for ensuring that all staff employed or engaged by {{org_field_name}} receive effective supervision, appraisal, and opportunities for reflective practice. Supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice are essential to maintaining the quality and safety of care delivered by registered nurses, healthcare assistants, and other agency staff. They are also vital tools for promoting staff development, maintaining professional standards, supporting wellbeing, and ensuring continuous improvement. This policy outlines how {{org_field_name}} will deliver supervision, appraisal, and reflection in line with legal and regulatory requirements, including the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, the Care Quality Commission (CQC) Fundamental Standards, the NMC Code, and Skills for Care guidance.
2. Scope
This policy applies to: All temporary staff employed or supplied by {{org_field_name}} including registered nurses, healthcare assistants, and other care staff working under zero-hours or flexible arrangements. Directors and office-based staff responsible for implementing and overseeing supervision and appraisal. All supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice activity carried out by {{org_field_name}} as part of the agency’s commitment to professional development, clinical governance, and regulatory compliance.
3. Related Policies
- Staff Support and Wellbeing Policy – Training and Development Policy – Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion Policy – Safeguarding Adults Policy – Whistleblowing Policy – Disciplinary Policy – Code of Conduct
4. Policy Statement
{{org_field_name}} is committed to: Ensuring that all staff receive regular and meaningful supervision, appraisal, and opportunities for reflective practice. Embedding supervision and appraisal as integral to maintaining safe and high-quality care for service users. Ensuring that supervision provides both accountability and support to staff. Promoting reflective practice to enable staff to learn from their experiences, improve professional judgement, and enhance their practice. Meeting regulatory expectations and industry best practices in the management and development of staff.
5. Definitions
Supervision is a formal process of regular, planned, and supportive discussions between staff and a supervisor (in this case, usually a director or senior member of the agency) to review performance, address challenges, and plan professional development. Appraisal is an annual formal review of performance, achievements, learning needs, and goals for the future. Reflective Practice is the process by which staff review and learn from their experiences to develop their skills, knowledge, and practice.
6. Responsibilities
Directors The directors of {{org_field_name}} are responsible for: Establishing and maintaining a system of supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice. Acting as supervisors for all agency staff or delegating this role appropriately. Ensuring that staff are provided with induction, supervision, appraisal, and access to reflective practice. Providing constructive feedback to support staff development. Identifying training needs through supervision and appraisal and ensuring appropriate learning opportunities are provided. Maintaining accurate records of supervision and appraisal.
Temporary Workers and Agency Staff All staff are responsible for: Engaging actively with supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice. Preparing for supervision and appraisal meetings, including reflecting on their own performance. Being open and honest about challenges and development needs. Using supervision to seek advice, support, and guidance on professional issues. Implementing learning identified during supervision and reflective practice into daily practice.
7. Supervision
Supervision will be provided to all agency staff through: Planned supervision meetings with a director or designated supervisor. Supervision at least annually as a minimum, but more frequently for new staff, those returning after a break, or where issues are identified. Supervision sessions that may be individual or in small groups where appropriate, depending on the needs of the staff member. Topics to be covered during supervision will include: – Review of recent work and placements. – Reflection on practice, including successes and challenges. – Review of adherence to agency and client policies, codes of conduct, and regulatory requirements. – Discussion of wellbeing and support needs. – Identification of learning needs and training requirements. – Career and personal development planning. Records of supervision sessions will be documented, signed by both parties, and retained securely by {{org_field_name}}.
8. Appraisal
All staff will receive an annual appraisal, which will: Review performance across the past year. Assess whether objectives from previous appraisals and supervisions have been achieved. Identify learning and development needs. Set objectives for the following year. Provide an opportunity for staff to give feedback on the agency’s support, placements, and development opportunities. Be documented, signed, and retained securely. Agency workers will be offered appraisal even if they are on zero-hours or ad-hoc arrangements. Participation is strongly encouraged to support professional development and maintain placement opportunities.
9. Reflective Practice
{{org_field_name}} encourages all staff to engage in reflective practice by: Reflecting on their experiences during supervision and appraisal discussions. Keeping informal reflective notes if they find this helpful (in line with confidentiality rules). Using structured reflective models (e.g., Gibbs Reflective Cycle) when appropriate. Using reflection to identify what went well, what could be improved, and how to apply learning in future. Directors will support reflective practice by: Encouraging open discussion of learning from incidents, complaints, or complex cases. Embedding reflective practice into supervision and appraisal discussions. Supporting staff to use reflection to improve quality of care and enhance personal resilience.
10. Confidentiality
Supervision and appraisal discussions will be treated confidentially, subject to safeguarding and safety requirements. Records will be shared only with those who need to know to support staff development or manage concerns. Staff are encouraged to be open and honest in supervision, knowing that concerns discussed will not lead to adverse action unless safety, safeguarding, or professional conduct issues are identified.
11. Managing Poor Performance
Where supervision or appraisal identifies concerns about a staff member’s competence or conduct: The issue will be discussed openly with the staff member. An action plan will be agreed upon, including training, mentoring, or increased supervision if appropriate. Where necessary, formal processes such as capability, disciplinary, or safeguarding procedures will be followed in line with {{org_field_name}} policies. Directors will monitor progress and provide ongoing support.
12. Equality and Diversity
{{org_field_name}} is committed to ensuring that supervision and appraisal are conducted fairly and without discrimination. All staff will be treated with dignity and respect. Reasonable adjustments will be made to supervision and appraisal arrangements for staff with additional needs.
13. Training and Support
All supervisors will receive training on: Effective supervision and appraisal skills. Reflective practice facilitation. Handling concerns identified during supervision or appraisal. All staff will be provided with information and guidance on: The purpose and benefits of supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice. How to prepare for supervision and appraisal.
14. Record Keeping
Records of supervision and appraisal will: Be stored securely and confidentially by {{org_field_name}}. Be retained for the duration of the staff member’s relationship with the agency and in line with data protection laws. Be available to regulatory bodies if requested as part of an inspection.
15. Monitoring and Quality Assurance
The directors of {{org_field_name}} will: Monitor the implementation of supervision, appraisal, and reflective practice. Review supervision and appraisal records (with consent) as part of quality assurance processes. Review the effectiveness of this policy annually. Seek feedback from staff about the supervision and appraisal process to identify improvements.
16. Continuous Improvement
{{org_field_name}} will use feedback from supervision, appraisal, complaints, incidents, and staff surveys to: Improve supervision and appraisal processes. Enhance training and development opportunities. Support the wellbeing and professional development of all staff.
17. Policy Review
This policy will be reviewed annually by the directors of {{org_field_name}} or sooner if: Changes in legislation or regulatory guidance occur. Feedback from staff or clients suggests a need for revision. Issues are identified through audits, complaints, or incidents.
Responsible Person: {{org_field_registered_manager_first_name}} {{org_field_registered_manager_last_name}}
Reviewed on: {{last_update_date}}
Next Review Date: {{next_review_date}}
Copyright © {{current_year}} – {{org_field_name}}. All rights reserved.